Antifascism per Butler_
13   november

The fallout from the American ideological war and the democratic crises. A conversation with Judith Butler

Speaking with Judith Butler about the state of American democracy during her time as a visiting professor at the Scuola Normale Superiore, it was hard not to think of the midterm elections that would have taken place a few weeks later. After a lecture in which about fifty graduate students had posed complex theoretical and methodological questions, she sat down at Palazzo Vegni, one of the Florentine branches of the Scuola Normale Superiore. Her habit of giving interviews and often being the subject of controversy, whether for her work or her comments on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, made the job of asking questions easy.

Years ago, she wrote Who’s Who Afraid of Gender?, a book in which she deconstructed the idea that there is a “gender ideology,” a concept, if anything, coined by those who believe that gender should not be discussed. During the midterm election campaign, the Republican Party revived all the polemical “anti-gender” paraphernalia.

“Gender ideology is an invention of those who oppose the concept, the word, gender studies, and gender policies. There is no such thing as an ideology. Rather, it is an insult, formulated and perpetuated by the right-wing opposition, to gay, lesbian, and transgender rights, feminism, anti-discrimination and anti-harassment laws, public policies, and laws against sexual violence or femicide. It is a term used to belittle and dismiss academic research and social policies that are based on the concept of gender or that seek to understand the power relations between men and women and the way gender and sexuality are addressed in society. This push originated outside the United States in reaction to intellectual and social policy trends developed there.

We can trace the movement’s origins to Russia, Argentina, Chile, and various theologians and politicians of the conservative right. I believe, however, that some authoritarian states have exploited and heightened the fear of the loss of traditional values to increase the power that the constitutional order attributes to them and to undermine democratic institutions.

 

It’s been about three years since the publication of Who’s afraid of gender. What were the consequences of this ideological war?

In the United States, we had constitutional protection for abortion. It was a woman’s right to choose. And now, after a Supreme Court ruling that contradicts Roe vs Wade, the one that had established that right, that constitutional protection is no longer in place. With Trump’s second term, they have gone further, attempting to impose on education, publicly funded research, and the courts the idea that gender is an illegitimate category, that it should not be taught or even used in public policy.

This administration has also stopped issuing passports that allow non-binary or trans people. This, I believe, has created significant difficulties for many trans people who wish to travel without renouncing their identity. Those who applied for passports during the Biden administration remain valid, but obtaining a new one is impossible. We must conform to the sex assigned at birth. We are also witnessing profound changes in primary and secondary education, so children and young people cannot learn about the lives of gays and lesbians. They cannot learn about feminism or the fight for women’s suffrage, nor the history of slavery or what is called systemic racism in the United States. Many states have adopted new rules about what can and cannot be taught. In some cases, we’re not even allowed to explain the massacre of Native Americans or the arrival of slaves in the United States as part of our history.

As president, Obama tried to open a discussion on national history, believing it was important that it be taught so that we could be critical of that tradition and become a different country. Trump, on the other hand, doesn’t want it taught because it damages his reputation. There’s a long list of words we can’t use, and “gender” is just one of them. There is a long list of books considered unacceptable.

 

We have witnessed an institutionalization of the discourse on gender ideology. Secretary of Defense Pete Heghseth has often talked about purging the military of “transgenders, queers, and people with low testosterone.” When this kind of discourse comes from a high-level position, anyone feels entitled to say anything…

I will answer with a joke: Hegseth is talking about the composition of the armed forces. He wants real men, and if they’re not yet virile enough, he wants them to take testosterone. He’s imitating what trans men do. He’s taking a cue from trans masculinity to help the military become more masculine. It’s very interesting when straight men start imitating trans men to achieve more appropriate masculinity.

More seriously, his speeches have effects that go far beyond military policy. Is it fair to call someone strange? Is it fair to say that this man, who isn’t masculine enough, is somehow weak or stupid, or can easily be denigrated or dismissed? It’s a culture of ridicule and contempt that is reproduced at the highest levels of government.

 

Speaking of teaching and books removed from libraries, what was the attack on universities?

It’s important to remember that both Obamas are well-educated. They studied at Harvard, they excelled in their fields, they are intellectuals. They are black and have achieved significant milestones. Aside from several disagreeable things, for many, Obama’s election was a cultural revolution: a black, elegant, intelligent president, well-regarded internationally. Trump has always been jealous, furiously jealous, of Obama’s admiration. And I think he made that clear on several occasions. But Obama also represented an educational system that had evolved over time to ensure that people of color could succeed in institutions that had traditionally been discriminatory and exclusionary.

Then there’s an anti-intellectual anger: who are these elites who go to Harvard, who speak a certain way, and who look down on everyone else? I believe the anger against affirmative action policies (policies that promote the participation of people with certain ethnic, gender, sexual, and social identities in contexts where they are underrepresented, anti-racist social policies, and higher education as a bastion of liberal politics is deeply rooted. Trump’s most fervent supporters proudly display the vulgarity: in the absence of a public higher education system, only the rich can afford a good university. Trumpism has used this argument to appeal to the working class, anti-intellectuals, and those who believe immigrants and minorities have opportunities that white workers are denied.

This resentment is also strong against feminism. What is this trans thing? What is this gender? These issues are portrayed as coming from elite institutions, from affirmative action , diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs, from left-wing intellectuals, both in journalism and education, who very often insist on narratives of oppression or emancipation.

There is anger, right-wing populist anger, over unemployment, the difficulty of owning a home or paying off one’s debts, the impossibility of leaving one’s assets to one’s children. But that indebtedness, precarious jobs, and loss of long-term financial security are Civil rights and social rights policies moved at different speeds, and the right used the advances on those fronts to explain the setbacks on the economic and social fronts.

 

Something similar happened with migration: if you’re worse off, it’s the new arrivals’ fault…

We cannot and must not underestimate the enormous right-wing and populist resentment that has resulted. It is up to us to address the issue somehow. We could simply call it silly talk, but then that’s exactly what’s expected. Simply, in my opinion, those who are unhappy with their situation are misplacing the causes of their unhappiness.

 

How did universities react to the Trump administration’s crackdown? And, if so, how should they have responded?

Many universities were terrified. They were unprepared for the idea that government funding could be used as a threat against them. Trump realized he could destroy them by withdrawing federal funding for scientific research, language learning, Middle Eastern studies, and all the various areas of research that had traditionally received public funding. Universities ended up being held hostage, forced to comply with the administration’s demands and face cuts in public funding.

Many universities, especially public ones, depend on federal funding to survive. Some faced massive cuts or closures and chose to give in to these demands for censorship, which obviously include accusations of anti-Semitism against young protesters or faculty protesting the genocide in Gaza. The Trump administration then demanded that those participating in the protests, which are a constitutional and human right, be punished. And if those who took part in the demonstrations hadn’t been punished, and if new campus policies hadn’t been introduced, the universities would have lost their funding. But opposing a genocide in Palestine isn’t anti-Semitism. Accusing the State of Israel of not representing Jewish values is not anti-Semitism. Indeed, it could be a way to save Jews from those who seek to represent all of them homogeneously, without making distinctions. In this case, the charge of anti-Semitism was leveled against these universities simply because they allowed their students and professors to protest.

Generally, the right of students to protest is not restricted. Police have intervened against protests related to Gaza, often violently. Many students have lost their chances to study, and some have lost their visas and had to leave the country. Several colleges and universities have succumbed to the government’s bullying; they have been unable to form a united front. Some institutions have been more courageous, but it’s also true that some of them are among the richest and most powerful.

 

Is there an awareness of the danger this climate represents? Or is there a sort of normalization, both of the attacks and of the idea of limiting the right to protest, of spreading fear in communities, of depriving people of their rights, of attacking institutions?

Both. I believe there are many people on the left who are reacting forcefully to this normalization of authoritarianism. They react vehemently precisely because this normalization is plain for all to see. Will we still have the right to habeas corpus, to know the charges against us if we are arrested, to be able to appear in court in person to hear the charges and present counter-evidence or give our version of events? We have lost fundamental legal protections that are integral to the very definition and spirit of democracy. Will we be able to regain them? Will immigrants and refugees enjoy the same rights as citizens? Will they have access to the same constitutionally guaranteed rights, and will these rights still exist? These are questions that remain unanswered today.

We therefore live in great fear that what we thought was a democracy is no longer one. And while we have rightly criticized American democracy as insufficient and perfectible, today we are losing hope of improving it because we are busy working to defend or restore what we had. On the other hand, there are large movements and spontaneous mobilizations against data centers, there are neighborhood groups against ICE patrols, and lawyers working pro bono to help people threatened with deportation. There are human and civil rights organizations trying to stop the deportations and hold the government accountable. Finally, I believe a renewed idea of socialism is emerging, a socialism with a very human face, not based on a state-centric idea, which focuses on major issues like housing, healthcare, and education. People are asking themselves: don’t we all have the right to live in a world where we can receive a proper education, access good healthcare, and have decent housing? What are the fundamental elements of our lives that we want to preserve? I’m witnessing some very positive movements, especially among young people, thoughtful criticism of Israel and a reexamination of the region’s history, as well as anti-war mobilizations that, in my opinion, could be more effective. A renewal of feminism in light of recurring acts of violence and sexual predation.

Even the coalition Trump thought he had built seems to be crumbling. And the Democratic Party has been forced to shift to the left. I’m watching these two trends with great interest. I haven’t lost hope. I haven’t lost hope at all.

Le conseguenze della guerra ideologica in USA e la crisi della democrazia. Intervista a Judith Butler